Here is a list of the entries:
chickenwings’ Narwhal
ab5597’s ocelot
sgtstickman’s fox
sgt_panda’s penguin
johnsonclan’s silverfish
bluino’s bunchie
Judges: alien5654, geric5, silarn
Judging Criteria: http://rimpo.net:8147/forum/viewtopic.php?f=13&t=55
There will be a first, second, and third place winners but only first place will get the prizes.
Here are my votes:
Entry #1: Narwhal by chickenwings
Theme: 5/5
Originality: 5/5
Scale: 4/5
Technical Proficiency: 7/10
Overall: 21/25
Entry #2: Ocelot by ab5597
Theme: 4/5
Originality: 3/5
Scale: 3/5
Technical Proficiency: 7/10
Overall: 17/25
Entry #3: Fox Head by sgtstickman
Theme: 5/5
Originality: 5/5
Scale: 3/5
(Only looses points in scale due to the fact he didn’t bother to finish the body)
Technical Proficiency: 9/10
Overall: 22/25
Entry #4: Penguin by sgt_panda
Theme: 5/5
Originality: 4/5
Scale: 2/5
Technical Proficiency: 5/10
Overall: 16/25
Entry #5: Silverfish by Johnsonclan
Theme: 4/5
Originality: 3/5
Scale: 3/5
Technical Proficiency: 4/10
Overall: 14/25
Entry #6: Bunchie by Bluino
Theme: 1/5
(Its basically a 3D pixel art)
Originality: 5/5
Scale: 4/5
Technical Proficiency: 6/10
Overall: 16/25
Here are my votes:
Entry #1: Narwhal by chickenwings
Theme: 5/5
Originality: 5/5
Scale: 4/5
Technical Proficiency: 7/10
Overall: 21/25
Entry #2: Ocelot by ab5597
Theme: 4/5
Originality: 3/5
Scale: 4/5
Technical Proficiency: 8/10
Overall: 19/25
Entry #3: Fox Head by sgtstickman
Theme: 5/5
Originality: 5/5
Scale: 3/5
Technical Proficiency: 7/10
Overall: 20/25
Entry #4: Penguin by sgt_panda
Theme: 5/5
Originality: 3/5
Scale: 2/5
Technical Proficiency: 6/10
Overall: 16/25
Entry #5: Silverfish by Johnsonclan
Theme: 4/5
Originality: 3/5
Scale: 3/5
Technical Proficiency: 4/10
Overall: 14/25
Entry #6: Bunchie by Bluino
Theme: 2/5
Originality: 3/5
Scale: 4/5
Technical Proficiency: 6/10
Overall: 15/25
Here is my version of votes in the theme I pilfered from alien:
Entry #1: Narwhal by chickenwings
Theme: 4/5
Feels like something is missing. It’s either half an animal or needs more indication of it emerging from the ground.
Originality: 5/5
A unique style earns you points.
Scale: 3/5
It’s big but it’s not that complicated.
Technical Proficiency: 7/10
Not that many materials, lots of flat colors, but nicely curved and the horn adds detail.
Overall: 19/25
Entry #2: Ocelot by ab5597
Theme: 5/5
No complaints.
Originality: 3/5
It’s like a lot of other box animals.
Scale: 3/5
Not huge and also has the worldedit look.
Technical Proficiency: 4/10
Block creatures simply don’t take a lot of effort.
Overall: 15/25
Entry #3: Fox Head by sgtstickman
Theme: 4/5
Losing a point because it’s just a head.
Originality: 4/5
Losing a point due to lack of asymmetry.
Scale: 2/5
Losing points because it wasn’t a completed animal.
Technical Proficiency: 9/10
Very impressive level of detail. It’s hard to build a degree of realism in a block world.
Overall: 19/25
Entry #4: Penguin by sgt_panda
Theme: 5/5
It’s an animal, and complete.
Originality: 3/5
Lack of asymmetry and I get an angry birds vibe.
Scale: 3/5
Large but not massive, and not a lot of detail.
Technical Proficiency: 7/10
Much like the narwahl but not to the same degree.
Overall: 18/25
Entry #5: Silverfish by Johnsonclan
Theme: 4/5
Point knocked off because this is clearly not the living silverfish and is a variant of the Minecraft silverfish.
Originality: 3/5
I like the geometric details but it’s based on minecraft.
Scale: 2/5
Fairly small, each one is not very different from the next.
Technical Proficiency: 7/10
Few materials, but there is some detail in the execution.
Overall: 16/25
Entry #6: Bunchie by Bluino
Theme: 0/5
This is not a real animal, it does not fit the contest.
Originality: 1/5
This is based on another living person’s artwork.
Scale: 3/5
It’s large, and the 3D extension earns some points.
Technical Proficiency: 3/10
One material, three colors, and a guide for how you should build it based on the original artwork.
Overall: 7/25
1st:
chicken: 61/75
stick: 61/75
2nd:
ab: 51/75
3rd:
panda: 50/75
Runners up:
johnson: 44/75
Bluino: 38/75
Since we have a tie for first place, and I haven’t really thought about what to do in a tie-breaker… I’m going to give it to both of them this time around, but I’m going to figure out something for future contests.
NARWHALS PREVAIL!
Not to mention Stick’s epic fox head!
It says I need to be in a station to go to my home :I
wait what… I figured it made an exception for homes… since they are homes… well I’ll look into it soon.